speck presidio ultra rugged case vs otterbox defender for iphone xs max

The new iPhone XS Max is a beautiful blend of glass and stainless steel, and you might want to cover it up because a pricey smartphone like the new iPhone XS Max deserves a lot of protection. Have a look at our comparison between the Otterbox Defender and Speck Presidio to help you choose the best rugged case with a holster and since both come with a holster, but there’s a $10 difference. Let’s find out more below!

Speck Presidio Ultra Rugged Case for iPhone Xs Max

speck presidio ultra rugged case for iphone xs max

Meet the slim rugged case from Speck Presidio with 15-foot drop-protection with impactium ultra bumper to absorb and disperse shock. This case is 16% slimmer than the leading rugged case but has been dropped from 15-foot multiple times by independent labs to ensure superior protection. The case consists of four tough and durable layers to provide ultra protection- Two layers of impact rubber and two layers of polycarbonate to withstand extreme drops. Removing the ultra bumper is easy with a no-slip grip.

The raised bezel screen protection gives phone screen extra protection from scratching and shattering if your phone falls and lands face-down. The screen works with most screen protectors and is easy to remove. The case also comes with a rugged holster. The holster has a 360-degree belt clip that doubles as a phone stand to watch movies. Moreover, there’s a port, button covers and a mute switch dial protect against dust and dirt with 360-degree port protection.

Pros :

  • 16% slimmer than the leading rugged case
  • Bonus holster for media vieing or belt clip
  • Port and button covers to protect against dust and dirt

Cons :

  • The case feels thin and fragile
  • No built-in screen protector
  • Not waterproof

Otterbox Defender Screenless Edition Rugged Case for iPhone Xs Max

otterbox defender screenless edition rugged case for iphone xs max

Introducing the first rugged case from Otterbox, the Otterbox Defender. The case has a polycarbonate shell & synthetic rubber slipcover, and multi layers of protection minimize the chance for accidental drops. The front is raised above the display, so there are some gaps if you set your phone face down on a table.

The OtterBox Defender also includes a holster like the Speck that can be used as a belt clip that rotates around 360. The holster also can be used as a hands-free kickstand so that you can watch any movies on your iPhone. It’s also stronger than the Speck when you make it stand to watch movies.



  • The case and holster is really tough and rugged
  • Comes with a strong holster for media viewing and belt clip
  • Port covers that block dirt, dust getting into jacks and ports


  • Does not come with a screen protector
  • Feels bulky in the pocket
  • Not waterproof


The Otterbox and Speck have things in common. Both cases have multiple layers of protection, comes with a holster, and you can turn the holster 360° for both cases but the strongest case goes to the Otterbox Defender. Both cases are not waterproof so make sure not bring it in the deep water and go diving for hours.

However, the iPhone Xs Max has a water-resistance rating of IP68 which mean it’s capable of being immersed in water for up to an hour. You can bring both cases into the water for an hour but note that both cases are not waterproof, but the iPhone Xs Max is water resistant with for up to one hour in the water.

Buy Online Otterbox Cases for iPhone XS Max

Buy Online Speck Cases for iPhone XS Max

Buy Online Cases for iPhone XS Max

International order